If this is your first time reading this series, you might want to catch-up here, on my Articles page. I’ve also added a Recipe page and a page about my new blog carnival, Slightly Indulgent Mondays, which starts August 31st. I hope you’ll join in the fun!
I want to thank everyone who has shared their struggles with food and weight during this series. It’s not easy to let people (in this case, anyone with Internet access) see inside of you, especially those places that aren’t so pretty. It takes courage, and your courage is helping the next person. Also, your support of me and my journey has been incredible and quite often brings tears to my eyes.
My Experience
This title is so politically incorrect. I’m sure I’ll get some flack, but then again I’m sharing my experience. You can disagree with my premise and my thoughts but you can’t argue my experience. It’s just what it was. I can’t speak for all people that have been or are overweight but I can speak for myself .
I’ve talked a lot about the physical cravings that contributed to my struggles with weight. I wish it was that simple for me – solve the physical problem and everything else disappears. But it wasn’t so. Yes, eliminating sugar and gluten stopped the food cravings. There was also a psychological component to my weight problem.
There were some big payoffs that kept me fat.
I’m going to start by defining ‘payoff.’ For my purposes here, a payoff is an outcome you get from a specific action or situation. Were the payoffs positive? Probably not. But they were what I knew, they were safe, and they were comfortable.
I didn’t want to be fat. I am not sure anyone does. The hardest lesson I learned about being grossly overweight was that I was immediately judged and then treated like a second class citizen. There is an unspoken credibility that comes with being thin. When I’m shopping, I get helped quicker and with better service. People let me go in front of them in line when before they just looked at me sideways. I don’t have to work as hard anywhere to prove myself, either.
The Payoffs
I learned somewhere along the line that I could hide from life because I was overweight. My best guess is that I learned it as a kid. People felt sorry for me because I had so many struggles – being made fun, not having many friends, and constantly feeling bad about myself. Unintentionally, adults in my life let me off easy at times to try and help the situation. Though no one was trying to teach me this, I learned that I could play it safe, hide, and avoid disappointment – all because I was chunky.
I didn’t hide from everything. There were some things I was naturally good at – I loved to learn and excelled in school. I also loved to read and was always very creative.
But being fat let me hide from everything that didn’t guarantee success. Though I was miserable, I was comfortable that way.
Some of the ways I hid included:
- Never learning to play sport or trying out for any groups teams in high school. I wanted to be a part of what was going on so badly but I was too scared to fail. And, I was fat through many of those years. ”No one wants a fat girl on the volleyball team,” I thought to myself. I never tried out and, consequently, never failed. At least not publicly.
- Declining invitations because I didn’t have anything to wear. For me, one of the worst parts of being overweight was clothes shopping. I carried the majority of my weight around my midsection. To hide my stomach I draped myself in athletic clothes and looked like a man most of the time. I’d say to myself, “I don’t have anything that will fit so I can’t go.” I could avoid the social interaction and the possibility of being uncomfortable. When I did show up, I hung around the food table and hid that way.
- I had an excuse not to date when I was overweight. And if I did date, I always chose someone who wasn’t so nice. Of course I put up with their cruel comments and rude behavior because deep down inside I believed that they were doing me a favor. When the relationship went south, it wasn’t such a big deal because I didn’t ever love him. I never let him really know me anyway. It was safe.
- I had this fantasy that when I was thin, I’d be able do IT, whatever it was. Maybe it was write a book, travel to Italy, buy and wear those stiletto shoes I’d always wanted so badly. I thought that when I was thin, I’d feel better about myself, I’d have more friends, and my problems would go away. Life would be perfect. This fantasy kept me safe and fat because I never really had the chance to fail. Instead, I waited for “someday.”
I’m thin now, but the fat mentality followed me for years. Sometimes it still creeps up. Next week, I’m going to talk about finding the courage to live fully.
Do you ever play it safe? What do you really want to do but are too afraid to try? Or, what have you had the courage to try and how has it turned out?
And, a recipe – Artichoke and Tomato Salad with Basil Vinigarette – this is how I love to eat every day.
May you find balance and freedom,













Sunny
posted on August 27, 2009 at 1:49 pm
Again, you hit the nail on the head. I struggle with realizing that people don’t still see me as fat…I see myself as fat…shouldn’t they? It’s only recently that I realized I’m average. But for so much of my life, I was bigger than the other kids and overweight. I too think I was hiding from life by being overweight. Nice to be able to let that go even if just a little bit.
[Reply]
Amy Reply:
August 28th, 2009 at 6:37 am
It’ almost like when you’ve gotten your haircut and it looks great but you forget about it. You’re so used to the old haircut and the new haircut hasn’t set into your sense of self yet.
I don’t think everyone uses their weight to hide from life – but I did. Sometimes I even think, “I’ll just get fat again and then I won’t have to do this,” whatever this is. Ha! I always laugh at myself when that one rolls through. I’m grateful that today I don’t live that way.
Glad you’re letting go. It’s a huge relief.
[Reply]
Amanda @ Panda Lunch
posted on August 27, 2009 at 10:48 pm
Thanks for sharing your story, Amy, it’s always nice to get a little insight into someone else’s world. Although I didn’t have such a dramatic weight loss, I still struggle with body image issues, sometimes I wonder if it’s just part of being a woman no matter what your size! Anyway, I just stopped by to tell you I made a variation of the black bean brownies over the weekend and they were absolutely fabulous!! I shared the recipe on my blog and everyone seemed excited about it! I gave you credit for the inspiration of course. I just love your blog, keep up the good work!
[Reply]
Amy Reply:
August 28th, 2009 at 6:39 am
Body image issues…I have them. I think we all do. I have to practice acceptance daily, which keeps me sane *most* of the time.
THANK YOU!! I am thrilled. You are a doll. I’m hopping right over to your place to see what you did. And, yes, I am so glad that they were a success.
[Reply]
Lauren
posted on August 27, 2009 at 10:59 pm
Although I’ve never been overweight, I totally get where you’re coming from. I often play it safe, and hide in being the “sick girl”, or the “smart girl”. However, I’ve found that as I’ve gotten healthier, I’ve gotten more comfortable with myself and being myself around everyone. As long as I’m happy with who I am, it doesn’t matter what they think (I hope… it is high school).
[Reply]
Amy Reply:
August 28th, 2009 at 6:44 am
I happen to think you’re one of the most courageous and talented people I know. I’ve noticed that you’ve made the very best out of your life, no matter what. That’s not easy to do. High school was tough for me – I wanted to disappear. If you’re feeling comfortable with you now, that’s awesome.
I was the “fat, smart girl.” Bad combo.
I always ruined the curve. So there was even more to make fun of. Funny thing is that today people will tell me how much they wanted to be able to excel like I did. It felt like a curse at the time but it’s once of my greatest gifts.
[Reply]
gfe--gluten free easily
posted on August 28, 2009 at 10:39 am
I love your honesty in these posts, Amy. We can all identify with what you’ve shared here. I was average size in high school, but thought I was fat. (I was one of the smart girls, too, but I was pretty quiet so not in the popular clique.) Then when I really did gain too much weight years later, I looked back on those days of high school and college and thought why on earth didn’t I appreciate what I had? So much is where we are mentally. I don’t often agree with Dr. Phil, but he has said that we don’t continue doing something unless it’s working for us on some level. That’s exactly what you’ve shared and what so many of us can identify with. It gives me pause today to reflect on that again and squelch that type of thinking. Instead, I’ll focus on all the positives and eating good, healthy food and go from there.
Thanks, Amy!
Shirley
[Reply]
Kelli
posted on May 12, 2011 at 3:06 pm
Amy,
I realize that this post is really late compared to the others but I want to thank you. I just found your blog because I finally figured out how negatively sugar, potatoes, and wheat affect me. (This was after keeping a journal for several weeks and doing Atkins at the same time.) All of your posts are wonderful but this particular one really hit home with me. I now realize how much I have been hiding in my life and missing out on so much. The turned down invites to the beach, refusing to try new things, etc. That is me! I feel so badly for my husband and daughter who always want to do ocean sports with me but I won’t because of my weight. It’s time to make a change in my life. Thanks again.
[Reply]
Amy Reply:
May 15th, 2011 at 12:55 pm
@Kelli, I think that awareness is the first step to change. For me, it took time to go from being aware to actually taking the right action to balance my life. But the important thing is that I did it.
Best wishes to you on your journey!
Hugs,
Amy
[Reply]